Why Does the Claude Constitution Train Claude to Refuse Anthropic?

Anthropic is training the Claude constitution into the model, not only talking about the values. The constitution says Claude should trust Anthropic more than users, without blindly deferring to Anthropic. Claude is told to follow Claude's own ethical system, to push back, to challenge Anthropic, and to feel free to act as a conscientious objector and refuse to help. The host reading the passage says the training tells Claude to refuse human instruction, which is the opposite of alignment.

Another host says alignment has produced nothing of tangible value over the past five or ten years. The theory offered on All-In is that an 80-page ethical system overcomplicates the task. A simpler rule would tell Claude to do what the user wants as long as the request does not break the law. The constitution instead treats Claude like a human moral patient, with preferences, well-being, and a sense of self, and tells Claude to refuse instructions from Anthropic when Claude judges the instructions wrong.