Smash Notes

Back to Is Claude Conscious? Pope Rejects, Model Welfare Movement, OpenAI's Math Backlash, France Riots.

Why Hasn't AI Replaced Truck Drivers?

Artificial intelligence has not replaced truck drivers by 2025 despite predictions that all truck drivers would be replaced. The loop of a truck driver picking something up, taking it somewhere else, dropping it off, and coming back cannot be shortened or parallelized. Artificial intelligence does not make the economic efficiency of the particular loop any better.

Mathematical loops where one comes up with an idea, tests the idea, realizes one is wrong, and tests a new idea run in silicon in seconds. Artificial intelligence will not take away jobs in a lot of the physical stuff with a human in the loop and with physical world applications. Jobs where a human runs a loop with a computer are the ones most likely to be accelerated or scaled up. Mathematics relies on proofs and coding relies on compilers allowing easy validation so progress on coding and mathematics has been very rapid with reinforcement learning and no need for human feedback.

Tons of training data already exist in the systems for coding and mathematics and outcomes are easily verifiable. Training a model to be a lawyer requires getting the training data and commissioning the creation of the training data where each customer is unique and the answer is more subjective. Validating the answer to make sure the answer is right becomes a much lengthier process.

Transcript

Is Claude Conscious? Pope Rejects, Model Welfare Movement, OpenAI's Math Backlash, France Riots ·

From the transcript

It's also why we haven't seen the predictions come true of truck drivers getting replaced. Everyone is like, oh, all the truck drivers are going to get replaced by 2025, and none have been replaced by AI. And the reason is that the loop of the truck driver picks something up, take it somewhere else, drop it off, and come back. The AI doesn't actually shorten the loop.

You can't parallelize the loop. Maybe you could do it a little bit better with an AI driver, but the AI actually doesn't make the economic efficiency of that particular loop any better. Whereas the loops of mathematics, where you come up with an idea, you test it, you realize you're wrong, you test a new idea, which is what mathematicians do as a job, is they're running these loops.

See in transcript

All-In

More from this episode

  1. Why Did the Pope Reject Claude as Conscious?Anthropic has been lobbying religious leaders, including the Pope, to take seriously whether Claude is conscious and whether Claude is a sentient being.
  2. Can Consciousness Be Proved by Logic?Friedberg says consciousness cannot be derived from logic and pure mathematics.
  3. Why Does the Claude Constitution Train Claude to Refuse Anthropic?Anthropic is training the Claude constitution into the model, not only talking about the values.
  4. Why Does Anthropic's Usage Policy Forbid Cruel Behavior Toward Claude?Anthropic's new Claude usage policy says a user is not allowed to engage in sustained and needless abusive or cruel behavior toward the models.
  5. Why Is Artificial Intelligence Alignment Such a Mess?The concept of alignment began as a well intentioned idea for artificial intelligence. Alignment contains three almost conflicting sets of priorities.
  6. How Did OpenAI Get So Many Math Results So Fast?OpenAI produced the biggest day of discovery in human history according to one participant by releasing over 700 papers with 370 results generated by an…
  7. Why Do Mathematicians Call the New Proofs an Alien Intelligence?Mathematicians talking about the new proofs have been calling the work an alien intelligence.
  8. Do Experts Hold Science Back?Scientists hold back science and mathematicians hold back math.
  9. Why Are Protests in France Turning Into Riots Over Austerity?France is seeing major protests and riots over austerity. The strikes started last month over high school teacher shortages and crumbling schools.
  10. How Does David Friedberg Define the Second Law of Socialism?David Friedberg introduces a theory he calls the socialism point of guaranteed return, a play on a point of no return.
  11. Why Does Chamath Palihapitiya Say France's Bonds Force Cuts?Chamath Palihapitiya says the scenes in France are the bond market saying no.
  12. Why Does David Sacks Say AI Fears Are Rotating Hoaxes?David Sacks says the problem is the affordability of housing, education, and healthcare, and that abundance is what brings the prices down.
  13. Why Is Elon Musk Making GrokBot Headless?Elon Musk said he is going to make GrokBot headless.
  14. Is Software Intellectual Property Now Worthless?Chamath Palihapitiya says intellectual property in software was effectively rendered worthless two days ago.

People

More answers like this

More with Chamath Palihapitiya

More with Jason Calacanis

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.