Can Consciousness Be Proved by Logic?
Friedberg says consciousness cannot be derived from logic and pure mathematics. A person can debate consciousness, but nobody can prove consciousness and nobody can disprove consciousness. In science, an idea that is not proved stays a theory until evidence settles the question. Outside science and mathematics, Friedberg calls the same kind of unsettled idea a belief.
Calling artificial intelligence conscious creates a new belief system, Friedberg says. The claim does not spread by proof. The claim spreads by narrative, from person to person, with no evidence and no data. Over time a group forms around the belief, and the belief starts to organize power.
Is Claude Conscious? Pope Rejects, Model Welfare Movement, OpenAI's Math Backlash, France Riots ·
From the transcript
I think what we're watching is probably the birth of a new religion. And it probably, it's not going to be called a religion, but it's going to follow sort of the same principles, and it's going to have the same effects, which will ultimately be camps that have conflict with one another. For aggregation of power. The thing about consciousness is it cannot be derived from logic and pure mathematics.
Like, you can't prove consciousness. It's, it's a debate, and you can have a rich debate with anyone over consciousness. You can't prove it, you can't disprove it. And when humans prove something to be true using math, science, we use empiricism, which is data and logic, the connection of the sequence of things to derive something to be true or not.