Do Experts Hold Science Back?
Scientists hold back science and mathematicians hold back math. Experts construct systems to pace the frontier and to gatekeep the work so only experts determine progress in the field.
Eric Weinstein has been saying as much for a long time. Sabine Hossenfelder published a video yesterday about how experts were wrong. One scientist at one of the big energy labs building a giant super collider said super collider systems are giant welfare systems for scientists. Scientists focus on writing grants to get money to keep themselves employed even if the work is not productive and does not deliver a new product to the world.
David Friedberg calls it a shining-the-light moment for AI. Deeply specialized experts hold gated knowledge and a view that has to be trusted, and that trust gives only them the ability to determine the frontier.
Is Claude Conscious? Pope Rejects, Model Welfare Movement, OpenAI's Math Backlash, France Riots ·
From the transcript
Yeah, I think Eric Weinstein has had some of the best commentary on this, and you'll recall I interviewed him a couple of weeks ago.
Banger interview. Yeah.
He's been saying for a long time that scientists hold back science, mathematicians hold back math. That they have basically constructed and created systems that allow them to pace the frontier, that allow them,
to gatekeep it.
Yeah, to gatekeep it. And by the way, I don't tweet very much, but Sabine Hossenfelder's video that she published yesterday, she's a fantastic scientist who publishes these videos on scientific breakthroughs. And she talked a little bit about how the experts were wrong about AI. Again, she talks a little bit about how everyone's predictions about job loss were wrong, and why people got it wrong, and why the experts are wrong.