Why Did Lemonade Score an 8.5?
Duffy reaches 2016 and names Lemonade. Mike supplies the Pitchfork score, an 8.5. Mack calls the number a dip down, from the self-titled album's 8.8 to Lemonade's 8.5. Mike calls it a small dip and says the drop makes sense, with the longer argument saved for later in the episode.
Duffy adds the decade placement in the same breath. Lemonade is number 41 of the decade. The 8.5 is lower than the self-titled 8.8, and the decade list still keeps the album inside the top 50.
From the transcript
here we go. We're moving on to 2016's Lemonade,
8.5.
A
dip down for Lemonade. Yeah, yeah. Down for Lemonade, 8.8, 8.5.
But a small, a small dip, but, and I think it kind of makes sense. Well, we'll get into it, but yes.
number 41 of the decade, by the way. then we have 2018, a joint album with, Jay-Z, Everything Is Love, 8.2 B&M. They
know each other. I like, so. I love that that 8.2, my favorite thing about that 8.2 BNM is that it could have gone either way, and I love the thought that it could have gone to a non-BNM and broken her streak. But well, I mean, you could argue that it didn't because it's a collaborative album, but I love that it did get the B&M and it just, we've got a, we've got a perfect little four, little four.
Original audio is not currently available.