Smash Notes

Back to 49: Beyoncé.

Why Did Pitchfork Score Homecoming a 9.3?

Duffy reaches 2019's Homecoming and states the score, a 9.3 and Best New Music. Mike does not want a long debate. He calls it absurd to rate a documentary and pretend the live album is the same thing, and he compares the move to rating Bo Burnham's Inside as if the special were only a record.

Mack sets the scene for a listener who missed the earlier argument. Homecoming is the Netflix special Beyoncé put out, documenting her Coachella performance and the lead-up to it. He then reads the Pitchfork review of the album. Homecoming does not stand on its own as an album experience, separate from the film. It probably does not need to. Beyoncé and her sister Solange increasingly rely on visuals to paint a fully embodied vision that includes music. Homecoming, next to the concert film, feels as if it was never meant to be heard in isolation. Still, the review says, it could be one of Beyoncé's most important releases for how it illuminates her past and her future. Mack says that is the review that gave the album a 9.3 and Best New Music, and that the 9.3 is the highest rating of Beyoncé's career, handed to a live album. He thinks Pitchfork wanted an excuse to shout that Beyoncé is the greatest thing since Jesus Christ himself, and used a record they do not think deserves to be heard alone as a lifetime achievement rating.

Mike calls the same review a straight-up SEO grab. Search Homecoming, he says, and Pitchfork wants the visit, even while the review admits the album is not really an album.

Transcript

49: Beyoncé ·

From the transcript

9.3 BNM. And I'm sure we will discuss whether or not... We don't

need to. We don't need to. We know that it's bullshit. There's no reason to discuss the complete bullshit in it of rating a documentary and pretending that the live album is the same thing. It's like if you rated Bo Burnham's Inside. I

mean, do you want to get into it? Because I have the quote. We could definitely do it. I have the quote.

Let's dive. Let's do. Let's talk. Let's talk about this.

Okay, because that's... Is that the last one on the list, Duffy, anyways?

I have more talking points, but we can pause right here and just dive into a little Homecoming rant. We're going

to be dodging back and forth. I love it. I love it. It's going to be a very nonlinear, you know, psychedelic experience of a deep dive.

See in transcript

Original audio is not currently available.

Best New Podcast

More from this episode

  1. How Did Pharrell Williams Say Yes Without a Word?Mack steered listeners to the walk-on song Cash In, Cash Out, featuring 21 Savage and Tyler, the Creator, by Pharrell Williams, the man behind an ancient…
  2. Why Did Pitchfork Publish 39 Best Albums?Duffy says Pitchfork has paused the mid-year list, the click bucket he looks forward to at Stereogum.
  3. Did Duffy Try to Cancel Animal Collective?Mike says Duffy started the effort to cancel Animal Collective.
  4. Why Was Preacher's Daughter's 6.4 So Far From Metacritic?Mike calls Ethel Cain's Preacher's Daughter a fascinating new take on pop and a liked album.
  5. Why Does Duffy Pick Big Thief for Album of the Year?Duffy's pick for the number one or two spot is Big Thief.
  6. Why Did Pitchfork Skip Best New Music for Soccer Mommy?Pitchfork scored Soccer Mommy an 8.0 and skipped Best New Music. Mike recaps the last deep dive on Soccer Mommy.
  7. What Score Did Perfume Genius Get for Ugly Season?Mike says the actual retail pitch for Perfume Genius and the album Ugly Season was an 8.6 BNM.
  8. Who Leads the Best New Podcast Scoreboard?Mike reads the Best New Podcast statistics board out loud. He is in last place with 20.8 points.
  9. Why Does Mack Call B'Day a Bidet?Duffy reads Beyoncé's 2006 album title as Bidet, and Mike says that reading is correct. Mack says Beyoncé intends the name to be B-Day, as in Beyoncé Day.
  10. Why Did Sasha Fierce Only Score a 5.7?Duffy puts I Am... Sasha Fierce at a 5.7. Mike says the album contains If I Were a Boy, Halo, and Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It).
  11. Why Is Beyoncé's Self-titled Album Number Three?Duffy walks the Beyoncé scores forward from 2011. Four got a 7.8. The 2013 album, Beyoncé, got an 8.8 and Best New Music.
  12. Why Did Lemonade Score an 8.5?Duffy reaches 2016 and names Lemonade. Mike supplies the Pitchfork score, an 8.5.
  13. Where Did Formation Land on the Decade List?Duffy counts Beyoncé on Pitchfork's best songs of the decade. Formation is number 4. Countdown is number 28.
  14. Why Did Pitchfork Say Beyoncé Sounded Too Real?Pitchfork faulted Beyoncé for sounding too real. Mack reads the line straight from the review: most of all, Beyoncé just sounds too real.
  15. How Did Kanye West Change Pitchfork in 2010?Pitchfork gave Beyoncé's I Am Sasha Fierce a 5.7. Mike says a three year gap sat between the album and Four.
  16. Why Score Renaissance 8.8 After One Song?Mack says a turn against the record would already have shown up as cracks in the website text.
  17. Why Did Mike Hate Saying Beabadoobee?Mike hits beabadoobee's album Beatopia in the lightning round and says he hates all of it.
  18. Did Mike and Duffy Match on Black Midi's Hellfire?Mike scored Black Midi's album Hellfire an 8.3 and called a B&M. Duffy had already landed on the same 8.3 and the same B&M, and he was pissed they matched.

More answers like this

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.