Smash Notes

Back to Nate Silver Predicts a ‘Momentous’ Midterm, with Nate Silver.

Why Can Democrats Win Senate Races in States Donald Trump Won?

Nate Silver says the Senate map opened because the story after 2024 was wrong, not because midterms stopped punishing the president's party. The steadiest pattern in American elections is a backlash against that party, a little larger in a lame-duck term. An average midterm moves the country about seven and a half points against the president's party from the previous presidential year. This year looks closer to an 11-point shift. Donald Trump won Ohio by about 11 points, and he won a run of these states by 10 to 13, so a shift of that size makes Ohio a toss-up.

Candidate quality moves less than the national swing, about five points at most. Roy Cooper is a strong Democratic recruit in North Carolina. Texas was a Trump plus 13 state, so an 11-point swing leaves it only slightly Republican, and Ken Paxton has to be a weak enough nominee to turn that into a Democratic lead. Ezra Klein put Democrats above a 70 percent chance of winning the Senate in the model. That chance is the swing plus those candidate gaps.

Transcript

Nate Silver Predicts a ‘Momentous’ Midterm ·

From the transcript

And given everything we know about partisanship in modern America, that wasn't going to happen. So we're talking about two weeks before the election right now. It'll be less by the time this airs. Democrats are at a 70 plus percent chance of winning the Senate in your model and not just winning the Senate, but possibly winning like beyond that.

Yeah. Why? What happened? So, I think a couple of things happened, and some of them have to do with expectations maybe being miscalibrated. You know, after 2024, there was talk of a, I guess, permanent conservative vibe shift, that Democrats were on their back heels, and Biden had failed, and wokeness... I was dumb, the idea that it'd be permanent.

Yeah. And if you look at the history of American elections, then the most regular trend in American elections, one of the few things that survives for decades is there is a backlash against the president's party at the midterm, maybe a little bit bigger if a president's in his second kind of lame duck term. But, you know, we can recite the exceptions on one hand, 1998 after Monica Lewinsky, 2002 after September 11th.

See in transcript

The Ezra Klein Show

More from this episode

  1. Why Does Nate Silver Call the 2026 Midterm Momentous?Nate Silver says this midterm feels momentous because a result in line with the polls would mark the end of the Trump era.
  2. Have Midterm Polls Underestimated Donald Trump?Nate Silver says midterm polls have not consistently underestimated Donald Trump.
  3. Why Do Some Midterm Polls Look Better for Democrats?Nate Silver says asking people whether they will vote, and how enthusiastic they are about voting, produces a very Democratic sample.
  4. How Many House Seats Would Democrats Gain?Nate Silver says a model with a 90% plus chance of Democrats winning the House still translates into only about 22 seats on average.
  5. How Did Florida Become So Red?Nate Silver puts Florida’s turn toward the Republicans at 75 percent migration and 25 percent a death spiral for the Democratic Party, a spiral he says might…
  6. Why Do Republicans Lose When Donald Trump Is Not on the Ballot?Nate Silver says Republicans lose the elections where Donald Trump is the dominant figure but is not himself on the ballot.
  7. What Has Pulled Down Donald Trump's Approval?Nate Silver says Donald Trump's approval in the second term tracks gas prices.
  8. What Is Nate Silver's Gut on the 2026 Midterms?Nate Silver's gut on the midterms is contradictory.

People

More answers like this

More with Ezra Klein

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.