Back to Cliff Sosin - Owning the Complements to Intelligence, with Cliff Sosin.
Why Should Kids Learn Math Without AI?
Cliff Sosin argues that children should learn foundational skills apart from models so they can direct a model. You cannot ask a model to treat a problem as a stochastic process unless you already know what a stochastic process is. A model could teach the term, but figuring it out that way adds a lot of friction. You do not have to work out the math, but you do have to know what it is.
Foundational skills build on one another, and children have to be able to do them without models. The point is not that later work will happen without models. If they cannot multiply, matrix multiplication is very hard to understand. They need not perform matrix multiplication especially well. They do need a high enough sense of what the model is doing so they can direct it. A bunch of time with kids should be spent separated from models, on basic skills judged important. Choosing which skills matter is a hard problem. The model can do the work, and the child still needs to know it in order to tell the model what to do.
An English teacher who rejects models because kids cheat on Shakespeare essays is not being ambitious enough. Give them work a hundred times harder and more ambitious, and have them use models to the fullest extent. They should bring the work product back. Make sure they did not just give a prompt to the model and submit the homework, and make sure they own it. Ask why the result looks the way it does and force them to justify it. Kids need to be good at using models, and they need to be taught that they can do anything.
Cliff Sosin - Owning the Complements to Intelligence ·
From the transcript
And so to direct the model to do your will, which I think is going to be an important skill in the future, you do have to understand something about the world. And smarts help for that. And education helps for that. You can't ask it to assume it's a stochastic process unless you know what a stochastic process is. It could teach you what one is, but that's a lot of friction in figuring this all out.
You don't have to work out the math, but you have to know what it is. And so when I've been thinking about education, there's this idea that you're teaching your kids a bunch of foundational skills that build on one another. Where I think in the end, the sum total of those, they have to be able to do them without models, not because they're going to do them without models in the future, but because if they don't know how to do multiplication, it's going to be really hard to understand matrix multiplication.