Why Do Ugly Ads Work for Technical Buyers?
Hector Serrano says a technical buyer should not be sold by an 18-year-old who is not technical. User-generated ads are not college kids with a camera. The user of a developer tool is often older, more serious, and not living on Instagram. For that person, the more boring and the uglier the ad, the better it performs. A screen recording of the product, a minute long or longer, can be a top ad and still look awful.
The same test applies to an expensive niche product. His example is a $3,000 sleep product. A buyer is not going to trust that pitch from a kid. People buy from someone who talks like them, works like them, and has the same problem. Creator ads can work at almost any company. They get harder as the price rises and the audience gets narrower, and the work becomes finding real users who want to talk about the product. He does not block an ad for looking rough. Some of the best ads he made a year earlier are a long vertical screen recording with a line of text at the top. They are also the ugliest.
How a 19-year-old intern built the growth engine behind this $2B AI company | Hector Serrano ·
From the transcript
I can't make content for my brand or I haven't had success with UGC. And a lot of times what happens is people mistake UGC for thinking it's just college kids making content. But UGC is user generated content. And if you're a dev tool, your user is probably going to be an older technical person. And you can't get by bringing on an 18 year old who isn't technical to talk about your product.
And those ads might look a lot different. They might look a lot different. Like for example, our technical ads at Whisper, when you're speaking to like this older demographic who isn't really on Instagram that much or isn't maybe a bit more serious, the more boring and the uglier the ads are, the better they will perform. And that can be something as simple as like a screen recording of someone using your product.