Smash Notes

Back to Why Instagram Changed Its Mind on Long Form Video.

Why Are Stand-ups Complaining About AI Characters?

Adam Mosseri says stand-ups are already complaining that their bits get stolen and then delivered by AI characters. Rights management for jokes is not a working system, and Instagram will not censor a post just for repeating the same joke. Treating the copies as unoriginal content is the path on the table, so Instagram can still reward the original creators.

Many of the characters run on scripts that pull the most viral Reels from the past couple of months or the past year and recreate them. Instagram does not rank AI-generated character accounts differently from human accounts when both are entertaining in a similar way. Accounts built as AI-generated characters now have to label themselves, because people should know whether they are looking at something real or not real.

Telling the difference keeps getting harder as the models get better. Instagram has technology that tries to detect AI, but automatic labels are risky: any classifier has false positives, and marking a real creator as an AI creator by mistake makes a lot of people angry. A carousel was classified as AI content, probably because of metadata from a tool, and the person who posted it took the flag as a compliment. Hate shows up in DMs whenever the labels go wrong. The balance is detection plus incentives for accounts to add the label themselves.

Grokipedia·Adam Mosseri·Instagram

Transcript

Why Instagram Changed Its Mind on Long Form Video ·

From the transcript

Yeah. Almost cartoony, but also real -looking. Yeah. Like on first glance, you're not fully sure what's going on. Yeah. But a lot of engagement and a lot of real engagement. Yeah. I, you know, obviously you look at this for long enough, you're like, okay, this is an AI -generated character. Yeah. And the question from a creator was around how Instagram views that account versus a human -generated account, right? Yeah.

And are they ranked differently or not if they are entertaining? Yeah. In a similar capacity. Yeah. So we don't rank them differently, but we think it's important that people have information. And so we're now actually starting to require AI accounts that are AI -generated characters to label themselves as such. Because we think it's important that people know what they're looking at is real or not real.

See in transcript

The Colin and Samir Show

More from this episode

  1. Where Is YouTube's Growth Coming From?Adam Mosseri says YouTube's time spent on devices in the US is flat, as best he can tell, and all of YouTube's growth is coming on television.
  2. How Did Threads Do in Its First Days?Adam Mosseri says Threads was wildly successful in the first couple of days, way more successful than any of them had anticipated.
  3. What Is Instagram Instants?Adam Mosseri says Instagram Instants is a quick way to get to the camera. It is a dedicated app, but you do not need the app.
  4. Why Does Instagram Create Value for Creators?Adam Mosseri says Instagram tries to create a lot of value for creators so they have a reason to post more to Instagram, or only to Instagram.
  5. Does Instagram Care Less About Watch Time?Adam Mosseri says Instagram focuses way less on watch time than the competition, and it still cares about watch time.
  6. Why Does Sends Per Reach Matter on Instagram?Adam Mosseri says sends per reach still matters a ton on Instagram, particularly for unconnected reach, the people who do not follow an account.
  7. Does Instagram Rank AI Content Worse?Adam Mosseri says Instagram probably does not rank AI content as well as content that is not AI, and he calls the judgment subjective.
  8. What Has Adam Mosseri Learned About What Works?Adam Mosseri says one of the most acute things he has learned is that what works today might not work in six months.

People

More answers like this

The other side

More with Colin Rosenblum

More with Samir Chaudry

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.